DIY Sailboats: Pool Noodle vs Sponge

Day 5’s gizmo is the power paddler.  Instead of purchasing the paddle boat from Group, we’re making DIY Sailboats, then having boat races!  We tried DIY Pool Noodle Sailboats and DIY Sponge Sailboats.  Today we’re going to compare the two types of DIY Sailboats.

This post may contain affiliate links.  I earn a small percentage of anything you purchase through these links but you don’t pay anything extra.  Thanks for helping to support Borrowed Blessings!  The prices referenced here are current as of publishing, but retailers change pricing often.

This year’s VBS theme is Shipwrecked {learn more about the theme here}.  The VBS kits are available now.  All of our VBS resources are designed to be used alongside any of the Group starter kits, although I HIGHLY recommend purchasing the ultimate version with digital.

*You can read our DIY Pool Noodle Sailboat tutorial and DIY Sponge Sailboat tutorial for details on how each sailboat was made.

I’ve compared several aspects of the sailboats below so you can choose the best type of DIY boat for your project!

Difficulty: The two types of sailboats were both quick and easy to make.

Size: The sponges are larger than the pool noodles, so the sponge boats have a slightly larger base.  Because of this, the sponge sailboats are more stable.

Supplies/Cost: The supplies are the same for each boat, aside from the actual sponges and pool noodles.  We purchased sponges (approx. 14 cents each) and pool noodles (approx. 4 cents each) at Dollar Tree.  The pool noodles are less expensive, but both options are budget-friendly.

Function (Which one worked better?): The sponge sailboat had a larger base, so it stayed upright much more easily.  The pool noodle sailboat toppled over quite often.  Either type of boat will be more stable with a shorter straw and smaller foam sail.

The bottom line? Although the pool noodle boats are less expensive, it was frustrating that the pool noodle sailboats fell over frequently.  Because of this, we’re using sponges.  If you’re going to use the pool noodles, just make sure you use short straws and sails and you should be okay!

I am a long-time Vacation Bible School lover.  I’ve lead in several capacities throughout the VBS world and am currently our church’s VBS director.  It is a joy for me to be able to share VBS ideas and resources with others!  I will continue to share VBS ideas here as we prepare for Shipwrecked VBS.  Follow the blog to see more of our ideas and planning!  Please let me know if there are any specific VBS items or ideas you need help with!